‘Memory Debt’ is a growing problem of the digital age – here’s how to stop it ruining your festive season

woman carrying baby

With the festive season approaching, the issue of overwhelm is at the forefront of many people’s minds. A bi-product of the digital age is that our mobile phones can be a huge contributory factor to this. Most people can’t live without their phones, for which they rely on for everything from banking to the weekly food shop, and of course taking photos.  And it’s the photos on our camera rolls which promoted Charlotte Ridley, Founder of Yoree, which is part of the global memory platform, Memorify, to coin the term ‘Memory Debt’.

 

What is ‘Memory Debt’?

‘We are arguably the most documented generation in human history,’ explains Charlotte. ‘Our phones contain thousands, sometimes tens of thousands, of photographs capturing birthdays, holidays, dinners, first days at school, friendships, pets, sunsets and completely ordinary Tuesdays. Yet I believe we are facing a strange paradox: we have never captured more of our lives, and yet we may be getting worse at actually remembering them. This is Memory Debt.’

Much like financial debt or technical debt, Memory Debt accumulates quietly. Every photograph we take with the intention that we will somehow organise it, revisit it or remember the story behind it later adds something to an ever-growing backlog.

‘Except, unlike our devices, human memory does not have unlimited storage,’ adds Charlotte. ‘Context fades. Details disappear. People leave our lives. And the story behind a photograph can be lost long before the photograph itself. A photograph is not the same as a memory.’

 

What’s the difference between photographs and memory?

‘We tend to use the words photo and memory almost interchangeably,’ explains Charlotte. ‘But they are not the same thing. A photograph is a piece of data. A memory is an experience reconstructed through context, emotion, sensory information, relationships and meaning.

We have built extraordinary technology for preserving the first. I am not convinced we have yet done enough to preserve the second. We have outsourced remembering to machines that mostly file.’

 

The science behind it

‘There is a well-established concept in cognitive science called cognitive offloading: using something outside our minds to reduce the cognitive demands of a task,’ explains Charlotte.

‘A smartphone reminder means I don’t have to remember an appointment. A contact list means I no longer need to memorise telephone numbers. A camera means I don’t need to rely solely on my own memory to preserve what something looked like.’

Researchers Evan Risko and Sam Gilbert describe cognitive offloading as the use of physical action to alter the information-processing requirements of a task, reducing the cognitive burden placed on us. [1]

‘There is nothing inherently negative about this,’ adds Charlotte. ‘Human beings have always extended our memory into the world around us, from written language and diaries to photographs and calendars.’

But digital technology has taken this to an entirely different scale.

Research published in Science found that when people expect information to remain accessible later, they can become better at remembering where to find that information than remembering the information itself. [2]

That made sense in a world of searchable facts. It becomes more complicated when the information we are outsourcing is our own life.

‘We increasingly behave as though pressing the shutter button has completed the act of remembering. It hasn’t,’ explains Charlotte. ‘The problem isn’t taking photographs. There is a temptation in conversations about digital wellbeing to arrive at a very simple conclusion: put the phone away. I don’t think that is particularly realistic, nor does the research support such a binary argument.’

One study published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, involving nine experiments and more than 2,000 participants, found that taking photographs could actually increase people’s enjoyment of positive experiences when photography increased their engagement with what was happening. [3]

That is important. The camera is not automatically the enemy of presence. Sometimes it makes us look more closely.

But other research has demonstrated what psychologist Linda Henkel termed the photo-taking-impairment effect. In experiments conducted during a museum tour, participants remembered fewer objects and fewer details about objects they had photographed than objects they had simply observed. [4]

Interestingly, the effect changed when participants photographed something more deliberately, such as zooming in on a particular detail.

The distinction is subtle but important.

‘The question may not be whether we take photographs. It may be how consciously we are engaging with the moment when we do,’ adds Charlotte.

 

From camera-roll overwhelm to Memory Debt

Most of us don’t experience our camera roll as a carefully curated autobiography. We experience it as a stream.

 

‘This is where I believe Memory Debt begins to accumulate,’ explains Charlotte. ‘We capture because capture is effortless, while the harder work of deciding what matters, adding context, connecting moments and returning to them has historically remained largely manual. The opportunity now is for technology to evolve beyond passive storage and help us do that work more intelligently, without taking the human meaning out of remembering.

 

But storage and memory are fundamentally different problems. Storage asks: Can I keep this?

Memory asks: Why did this matter? Who was there? How did it feel? What happened next? And when might remembering it matter again?

 

‘Technology has become exceptionally good at answering the first question. The next frontier should be helping us answer the others,’ says Charlotte. ‘Parenthood makes the problem impossible to ignore. You see this particularly clearly when you become a parent.

A baby’s first year can generate thousands of photographs. Parents document the milestones, certainly, but also the beautifully mundane things: how they slept with one arm above their head, the face they made tasting a lemon, the toy they carried everywhere, the way they mispronounced a particular word.

At the time, those details feel unforgettable. Then life moves. Five years later, the photograph may remain in perfect resolution while the context around it has almost completely disappeared.’

 

How to address Memory Debt and ease the camera-roll overwhelm

Childhood memory presents another fascinating challenge because our earliest life stories are not formed in isolation. Research into autobiographical memory shows how social context and parent-child reminiscing contribute to the development of children’s autobiographical narratives; more elaborative reminiscing is associated with more detailed and coherent autobiographical memories. [5]

‘This means the photographs we are accumulating are potentially far more valuable than simply being records of what our children looked like,’ says Charlotte.  ‘They can become prompts for storytelling, connection and shared remembering. But only if we actually return to them.

Memory should be part of the wellbeing conversation.’

 

When we talk about our relationship with technology and wellbeing, the conversation tends to focus on screen time.

‘I think there is another one we should be asking,’ says Charlotte. ‘And that is, asking if technology is helping us experience and remember our lives more meaningfully, or simply helping us document them?’

 

Autobiographical memory is deeply connected with our sense of self. It helps us construct the story of who we are, maintain relationships and connect our past experiences with our present lives. [5]

‘This is why I believe memory deserves a much larger place in conversations about digital wellbeing.’ continues Charlotte

‘Our digital habits do not just affect how we spend our attention today. They are increasingly determining what record of today remains available to us tomorrow. The answer isn’t digital abstinence. Nor should should we stop photographing our children, our friends, our holidays or the insignificant moments that unexpectedly become significant years later. Quite the opposite.

Technology has given us an extraordinary opportunity to preserve parts of human life that previous generations simply could not. But we need to move from indiscriminate capture to intentional remembering. That can start with remarkably small changes.’

 

The changes we can all implement to ease the ‘Memory-debt’

  • Take the photograph, then put the phone down and experience what happens next. Notice what you can hear, smell and feel.
  • When something genuinely matters, capture the story as well as the image. Revisit photographs with the people who were there and talk about what each of you remembers differently.
  • Most importantly, don’t assume that because something has been stored, it has been remembered.
  • Later, don’t just store the photograph. Add the story. Talk about it. Revisit it. Share the memory with the people who helped create it.
  • Pay down your Memory Debt, the future of personal technology should not be about remembering for us. It should be about helping us remember better.

 

‘Technology needs to evolve from storage to meaning,’ concludes Charlotte.  ‘For decades, the digital photography industry has largely been solving a storage problem. First we worried about how many photographs would fit on a memory card. Then how many would fit on a phone. Then how much cloud storage we needed to hold everything. Storage is increasingly solved. Memory isn’t.’

One day, the photograph may still be there in perfect resolution. The question is whether the memory will be too.’